Taste of New York Pizzeria

Reviews

• Daniel St.Pierre

  Aug, 05 2018
  ★ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆
  Worst Pizza EVER!
  
  I stopped by this place for a quick bite after playing 2 hours of ice hockey and needless to say, I was famished and when I first walked in the joint, it smelled so good I wanted to die!!!
  
  Although the service was OK, and the pie looked amazing, I could barely keep my first bite down... The dough was so off, I couldn't take another bite. Thank God for the Coke that saved me from choking! I washed that nasty mouthful of doughy cheese with the entire can of cola and called that experience over.
  
  For $10.65, I got 2 horrible slices of pizza, 3 dense meatballs and a can of Coke.
  
  Like I said, the Coke was awesome, but I'm pretty sure no one at New York Pizzeria had anything to do with getting soda in a can. LOL
  
  The meatballs were dense, and impossible for me to cut with plastic utensils. #Bummer b/c once again, they looked spot on but one bite was enough for me.
  
  What do I know about pizza and meatballs?
  
  I've had pizza all over the place, Montreal, Toronto, Vancouver, New York City, Chicago, San Fransisco, Orlando, Miami, Tampa, Berlin (in Germany), Cairo (yes, in Egypt!) and even Rome, the capital of all places, Italy. :)
  
  I am partial to Montreal pizza (3X Canadian pepperoni & cheese please!) although close second, and the only option on the menu here in Florida, authentic NY pizza. The pizza I had today at New York Pizzeria was, without a doubt, the WORST EVER.
  
  As for meatballs, I just wasn't impressed with them seeing how my 13 year old daughter Grace can do better (for much cheaper than $5.00!!!), and I'm certain of it, use fresher, healthier ingredients for example, eggs from our own chickens and ducks, beef & veal from our neighbor and pork from our own hogs (already in the freezer!)
  
  This place gets 1/2 star for the cold Coke and 1/2 star the cook who doubles as the host, who doubles as a server, who doubles as a cashier. He was alright. So, that's that.
  
  To him who has an ear, let him hear. #TGBTG

Photos and maps

Nearest companies

• Amscot - The Money Superstore

  Establishment, Atm, Finance

  17501 Preserve Walk Lane, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-977-4530

  amscot.com
• Tijuana Flats

  Establishment, Food, Restaurant

  17501 Preserve Walk Lane #103, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-975-0483

  tijuanaflats.com
• Lapels Dry Cleaning Tampa

  Establishment, Laundry

  17503 Preserve Walk Lane, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-605-2000

  mylapels.com
• Jenny Craig Weight Loss Center

  Establishment, Health

  17518 Preserve Walk Lane # 8, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-971-8043

  jennycraig.com
•  

  Verizon

  Establishment

  17501 Preserve Walk Lane Suite 101, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-972-4590

  verizonwireless.com
• MetroPCS Payment Center

  Establishment

  17501 Preserve Walk Lane #106, Tampa, FL 33647

  +1 813-977-4530

  metropcs.com